Naima Hirsch Gelman
Naima Hirsch Gelman is a writer, educator, and life-long student. She has previously developed Torah resources as the Rabbinic Fellow at the National Council for Jewish Women and built community as the Programming Director at the Beis Community. Naima completed an internship at the Hebrew Institute of Riverdale - The Bayit, and taught college students about Jewish approaches to sexuality at Hunter Hillel. She participated in the Va’Tichtov: She Writes fellowship and trained with Clal and JOIN for Justice. Naima earned her BA from Hunter College in English (Creative Writing) with a minor in Women and Gender Studies. She lives with her family in Savannah, Georgia.
In the fourth chapter of Masechet Gittin, the mishnah talks about how a man might nullify a gett:
בָּרִאשׁוֹנָה הָיָה עוֹשֶׂה בֵית דִּין בְּמָקוֹם אַחֵר וּמְבַטְּלוֹ.
Originally, they would assemble a beit din in another place and nullify the gett.
הִתְקִין רַבָּן גַּמְלִיאֵל הַזָּקֵן שֶׁלֹּא יְהוּ עוֹשִׂין כֵּן, מִפְּנֵי תִקּוּן הָעוֹלָם.
Rabban Gamliel haZaken decreed that they would no longer do this on account of tikkun olam.
Tikkun olam is typically associated with social justice, and while that’s incredibly important, our modern conception of social justice isn’t what the mishnah is talking about.
Instead, Rabban Gamliel is using his rabbinic authority to create a safety net, to protect women who would not have otherwise been protected. This is just one scenario where a man might fulfill the letter of the law during the gett process while still leaving his wife in a precarious position. There may have been nothing legally wrong with nullifying a gett in a different city - but Rabban Gamliel knew that it was morally wrong, so he corrected it.
I’ve spent the past four years thinking about what it means to be a rabbi. The answer is short and deceptively simple: to build a better world. To be a rabbinic leader is to help the world align with morality and Torah, to stand up when the “way it’s always been done” doesn’t work for the people on the margins. While my time as a Maharat student is ending, my rabbinate of tikkun olam is only just beginning.
Since arriving at Maharat in the middle of a pandemic four years ago, I have been filled with gratitude for the trailblazing women who came before me and paved the way for me to pursue the rabbinate. If not for women like Mrs. Esther Krauss, Rabbanit Chana Henkin, and my beloved teacher Rabbanit Devorah Zlochower, I would not be the woman nor learner I am today.
I am blessed with a love of learning that blossomed under the guidance of excellent teachers long before I started at Maharat. I am forever indebted to Rabbi Dina Najman who first opened the world of Gemara to me as a precocious eleven-year-old and continues to ensure that I find my place in the chain of tradition long after I left her classroom. Mrs. Rivka Kahan took the time out of her busy principal schedule to teach an elective for three students, illustrating just how seriously she took our learning while inspiring me to really sit with texts. I am indebted to Rabbi Jay Goldmintz for his patience with a cynical high school senior and his deep wisdom that continues to inspire me. Rabbanit Debbie Zimmerman not only taught me Torah but was a light in a dark time. My teachers at Drisha - Rabbi Dr. Jon Kelsen, Dudi Goshen, and Miriam Gedwiser - not only modeled a deep passion for learning but a true appreciation for the artistry within Torah texts.
My teachers and chavrutot at Maharat are a constant inspiration. Reb Jeff not only taught me the details of many textual contradictions but how to truly love halacha for all of its twists and turns. Rabba Wendy and Rabbanit Devorah model how to love Torah despite misogynistic texts. Rabba Sara taught me how to translate my ideas into something tangible and accessible. Maya Bernstein is a true Renaissance woman who continues to encourage me to go beyond what’s been done to what we might accomplish. Through her deep scholarship and attention to detail, Rabbi Erin convinced me that maybe I am a bit of a Hasid, after all. Reb Tanya and Rabbanit Liz - it is an honor to be your student and friend. My chavrutot - Leah, Tamar, Talia, and Sarah - have pushed me to learn more and better since my first day. I am indebted to your color coding, charts, memes, and note taking. Rabbis Steven Exler and Danya Ruttenberg are mentors par excellence and always encouraged me to pursue what I was interested in.
My path to the rabbinate was a surprise to me, but not to anybody else in my orbit. Hart Levine, my “co-conspirator” at the Beis Community, showed me with his trademark humor and humility that there’s more than one way to lead a shul community. Yael Brodsky Levine modeled how to engage communally on my own terms and how to have fun while doing so. I am so lucky to have benefited from my “frentor” Sarah Allen’s gentle nudging and deep wisdom. Erin Beser not only gave me a job but shaped me into the educator I am today. Rabbi Charlie Schwartz taught me what pluralism is and later gave me the chance to put it into practice for others. Lynda Bachman and Caroline Rothstein - thank you for your leadership and modeling creativity as a Jewish artist.
My chosen family has shaped me into who I am today. Tante Ellen and Uncle Shalom: I can’t put into words how lucky I am to be loved by you. Tante Cheved and Uncle Nathan: I am so grateful to have grown up in your home full of laughter, learning, and love. Miriam and Michael: thank you for the cookies, built-in friends, and years of coffee. Zahava, David, Ari, Gili, and Yonah: I have never felt at home somewhere as quickly as I did with you. The Zitter clan is responsible for a childhood belief that only girls learn Torah. Eliyahu and Aderet: you are the best teachers in how to love without abandon, ask good questions, and have confidence when nobody else does.
My biological family inspires me to do hard things because I know they’ll be there no matter what. The aunts in the “sister chat” (Aunt Jan, Mich, Auntie Steph) are perhaps the most tenacious, persistent, compassionate, silly, loving, and confidence-inspiring people I know. As I grow older, I appreciate my Uncle-uncle David and Aunt Sue more and more; they are not only loving “grandparents” but deeply committed citizens and inspiring communal leaders. Even though I didn’t get to know my Saba and Savta zt’’l as an adult, their legacies inspire me every day.
I am so lucky that in addition to my husband, I also have his family in my corner. Beth, Scott, and Melissa Gelman are the best in-laws I could dream up for myself. My dearest friends Nachi Lederer and Shai Wiesel have seen me through the awkward high school years until now. I am a better person because you love me.
There aren’t enough words to describe how my parents, Jordan and Marjorie Hirsch, have pushed me to do what I thought was impossible. I am forever grateful for a childhood home overflowing with radical hospitality, unconditional love, belly laughs, retold stories, and good music. Abba - your unique blend of cynicism and idealism continues to motivate me to be the best version of myself as a rabbi and person. Momma - your reassurance through uncertainty gives me a foundation upon which to build. Yak and Kopl - I am so lucky that I get to be a sister to such compassionate and goofy people.
I couldn’t have done any of this without the constant, unwavering support of Samuel H. Gelman, my chavruta in Torah and life who has been looking forward to being my rebbetzin since our first date. Thank you for being my rabbi.
And of course, thank you to the Ribbono Shel Olam who ensured that I was born at the right time and the right place to benefit from the support and love of all of these people and institutions.
Anat Sharbat
*$180.00
Mazal Tov to all the musmachot, and to Yeshivat Maharat.
We pray for the chatufim, the chayalim, and the Akurim.
Beis Community
$360.00
Mazel tov Rabbi Naima, we love you! Love the Beis (Yael, Hart, R Tanya, Sarah Allen, Marissa, Shimmy, Nathaniel, Maia, Shalhevet)
Rabbi Jason Herman, Executive Director, International Rabbinic Fellowship
*$180.00
Mazel Tov to everyone at Yeshiva Maharat and Yasher Kochachot to all the musmakhot. May you go mechayil el chayil!
Sarit and Jonathan Gribetz
*$360.00
Mazal tov Meytal, Yedidah, Dena, Meira, Rivka, Talia, Leah, Adina, Tamar, Miriam, Naima, and Rabba Sara! So proud of you!!!
Rabba Wendy Amsellem and Rabbi Mike Moskowitz
*$360.00
We are so inspired by what you have accomplished and so excited for the wonderful transformative work that you will do!
Samuel Gelman
$360.00
Mazal tov Naima! We are so proud of you!
Love, Samuel, Mom, Abba, Beth, Scott, Kopl, Yakir, and Melissa
Liz Shayne (and Family)
*$360.00
Mazal tov to all of you! It was such a zechut to learn with you and from you and to be part of your Maharat journey!
Jeannie Appleman
*$36.00
Shira Billet & Steven Exler
*$360.00
Mazal tov to Naima, Leah and Dena and all the musmachot with special appreciation for Rabba Sara and Rav Jeff's leadership!
Sarah & Elliot Kaufman
$180.00
Mazel tov to Naima, a wonderful chevruta and friend—חברותא או מיתותא. And mazel tov to all the musmachot!
Roberta and Fred Gelman
$180.00
Dina Najman and James Licht
*$180.00
Mazal tov to Rabbi Naima Hirsch, Rabba Sara, Rav Jeff, Dr. Lisa and the entire graduating Semicha class.
Rabbanit Tamar Green Eisenstst and Abe Eisenstat
*$10,000.00
Mazal tov to our amazing friends, colleagues, chevrutot, teachers, care providers, leaders, guides, wise souls and just general all around superstars. The rabbinate is blessed to have y’all join the ranks!
Adina and Farryl Roth
*$180.00
Dr. Sarah Stemp
*$180.00
Atara Lakritz
$18.00
Rabbi Marianne Novak and Dr. Noam Stadlan
*$3,600.00
Congratulations to all the musmakhot on your accomplishment!
Mordi and Rachel Raven-Chabin (name Order For R' Naima Hirsch Gelman)
$36.00
Julia Adelson
$36.00
Yocheved & Nathan Lindenbaum
$360.00
Jan Hirsch
$36.00
Bogner Family
$36.00